[Paper] Xiehua Zhu (Editorial Board Member of this journal), et al.: Development and Application of High-Efficiency PDC Drill Bits Based on the Critical Fracturing Theory of Rock Plasticity and Brittleness
Release date:
2025-06-13
Source:
Citation and reference format used in this article:
Zhu Xiaohua, Hu Hai, Liu Weiji, et al. Development and Application of a Highly Efficient PDC Drill Bit Based on the Critical Fracture Theory of Rock Plasticity and Brittleness[J]. Natural Gas Industry, 2025, 45(5):102-112.
ZHU Xiaohua, HU Hai, LIU Weiji, et al. Development and application of high-efficiency PDC drill bits based on the critical depth theory of plastic-to-brittle transition in rock cutting[J]. Natural Gas Industry, 2025, 45(5):102-112.
About the Author: Zhu Xiaohua, born in 1978, is a professor and doctoral supervisor, as well as an editorial board member of this journal. He currently serves as the President of Southwest University of Science and Technology and specializes in research areas such as tubular mechanics and drilling speed-up techniques. Address: No. 8 Xindu Avenue, Xindu District, Chengdu, Sichuan Province (610500). ORCID: 0000-0002-0507-3773.
E-mail: zxhth113@163.com
Abstract
The Tarim Basin, as China’s largest oil- and gas-bearing basin, boasts abundant hydrocarbon resources and immense potential for exploration and development. However, the Cambrian strata in the Tarim Basin are characterized by exceptionally thick dolomite formations, which are not only highly resistant but also extremely difficult to drill. As a result, conventional Polycrystalline Diamond Compact (PDC) drill bits exhibit low mechanical drilling rates and limited footage per bit when penetrating these dolomite layers. To address this challenge, a comprehensive study was conducted on the internal structure, mechanical properties, abrasiveness, and drillability of the Cambrian dolomite formations in the Tarim Basin. Building on existing PDC drill bit designs tailored for dolomite formations, the study optimized key parameters such as the type of primary cutting teeth, crown geometry, and blade configurations. Guided by the rock’s plastic-to-brittle transition theory for critical fracture mechanisms, researchers further refined the tooth arrangement and hydraulic design, ultimately developing a new, high-efficiency PDC drill bit specifically suited for the Cambrian dolomite strata. Field tests were then carried out to validate the performance of this innovative drill bit. The results demonstrate: ① The Cambrian dolomite formations exhibit strong heterogeneity, with a dense, robust structure and exceptionally high uniaxial compressive strength—reaching up to 221.51 MPa. These rocks possess moderate abrasiveness and show extremely poor drillability under high confining pressures. ② The newly designed PDC drill bit features an "shallow-conical crown combined with an extended gauge section," effectively minimizing torque fluctuations and enhancing drilling stability in dolomite formations. ③ The high-efficiency PDC drill bit, engineered based on the plastic-to-brittle transition theory, delivered remarkable improvements in drilling efficiency within the Cambrian dolomite sections, achieving a total footage of 603 meters and a mechanical drilling rate of 2.87 meters per hour. In conclusion, the DS675H drill bit, after successful field application, has set new benchmarks in the Tarim Basin—breaking both the record for the longest single-bit footage and the fastest mechanical drilling rate in dolomite formations. This breakthrough not only paves the way for more efficient drilling operations in the Cambrian and deeper strata but also provides critical technical support for accelerating and optimizing drilling in challenging, hard-to-drill formations at greater depths.
Keywords: Tarim Basin; Cambrian System; Dolomite; PDC Drill Bits; Non-Standard Teeth; Brittle-Ductile Transition; Efficient Rock Breaking; Drilling Speed-Up
Introduction
To ensure national energy security, China’s oil and gas exploration and development continue to push deeper into the Earth. Deep and ultra-deep formations have become the primary frontiers for major oil and gas discoveries in China [1-4]. The Tarim Basin, as China’s largest oil- and gas-bearing basin, boasts abundant hydrocarbon resources. Its proven geological reserves of ultra-deep oil and gas amount to 16.4 × 10⁸ tons, accounting for approximately 19% of the world’s total proven reserves [5], highlighting its immense development potential [6].
The drill bit is one of the most critical tools influencing drilling efficiency, with its performance directly tied to drilling costs and cycle times [7-8]. To achieve efficient development of ultra-deep oil and gas resources in the Tarim Basin, it is essential to rely on drill bits capable of highly effective rock-breaking capabilities. PDC (Polycrystalline Diamond Compact) bits have gained widespread use in various types of drilling operations due to their outstanding advantages, such as long life, excellent wear resistance, and superior impact toughness [9]. According to industry statistics from the oil and gas sector, PDC bits now account for more than 90% of the total footage drilled by all drill bits worldwide [10]. In the Tarim Basin, ultra-deep oil and gas resources are typically buried at depths exceeding 6,000 meters [11], with the Ordovician and Cambrian formations hosting exceptionally thick layers of dolomite [12-13]. Due to these extreme burial depths, the Cambrian dolomite formations exhibit dense, high-strength lithology, often containing silica and flint nodules in certain intervals—making them extremely difficult to drill. As a result, conventional planar-tooth PDC bits deliver unsatisfactory drilling performance in these Cambrian dolomite strata, frequently leading to premature bit failure and significantly prolonged drilling cycles [14]. For instance, in the LT1 well within the Tarim Basin, the challenging dolomite sections of the Ying 4 Formation, Penglai Dam, and Lower Quli Tag Group reach thicknesses of up to 1,480 meters. Yet, on average, each drill bit achieves only about 114 meters of penetration, with an average mechanical drilling rate of just 1.33 meters per hour—seriously hindering the efficient exploration and development of the underlying salt-trapped hydrocarbon reservoirs in the Cambrian. Therefore, developing advanced drill bits specifically designed for efficient rock-breaking in dolomite formations has become an urgent necessity.
Schlumberger optimized the tooth arrangement and blade structure based on flat teeth, while also incorporating a protective mechanism at the shoulder of the PDC drill bit. This innovation led to an 18% increase in drilling speed when applied to a dolomite formation in a gas well in Saudi Arabia [16]. Halliburton, on the other hand, opted for flat teeth and implemented a dual-row design featuring teeth with identical track and exposure height, boosting drilling efficiency by 30% to 40% in the dolomite formations of Norway’s North Sea oilfields [17]. Since then, to further enhance both drilling speed and stability in dolomite formations, drill bit manufacturers and oilfield service companies have begun integrating asymmetric or specially shaped teeth into the dual-row tooth configuration. For instance, Halliburton specifically developed the GT85WRKHO drill bit for the R-512 well in the Srednebotuobinskoye oil and gas field in eastern Siberia, Russia, where dolomite layers with compressive strengths exceeding 370 MPa were encountered between 850 and 950 meters. The GT85WRKHO drill bit features flat teeth in the front row and triangular teeth in the rear, resulting in a remarkable 120% improvement in drilling speed within the dolomite formation [18]. Meanwhile, Well Ta Shen 5 utilized Smith’s Z716-type PDC drill bit, which combines flat teeth in the front row with conical teeth in the rear. This design effectively minimized drill bit vibration, enabling the well to achieve an average mechanical drilling rate of 2.07 meters per hour through the Cambrian dolomite section [19]. Similarly, Well ZH2 in the Tarim Oilfield was equipped with a PDC drill bit featuring a hybrid tooth design—combining conical, triangular, axe-shaped, and flat teeth—which, when paired with a screw drill string, delivered an impressive mechanical drilling rate of 2.46 meters per hour in the dolomite formation [20]. Despite these advancements, PDC drill bits continue to face challenges such as chipping and wear when operating in dolomite formations, indicating significant room for further optimization.
Based on the aforementioned background, the author collected outcrops of Cambrian siliceous dolomite in the Tarim Basin and conducted comprehensive analyses, including rock structure, mechanical properties, abrasiveness, and drillability. Furthermore, integrating the existing PDC bit designs tailored for dolomite formations, a novel, highly efficient rock-breaking bit suitable for Cambrian dolomite strata was developed using the rock plastic-to-brittle critical fracture theory. Field tests were subsequently carried out at Well JT1 in the Tarim Basin. The results demonstrated that the PDC bit designed according to the rock plastic-to-brittle critical fracture theory significantly enhanced drilling speed, breaking both the previous record for the longest footage per bit and the highest mechanical drilling rate achieved in dolomite formations within the Tarim Oilfield. This breakthrough not only provides a promising technical approach for efficiently drilling below the Cambrian formation in the Tarim Oilfield but also contributes valuable technical experience for future operations.
1. Rock Properties
The density of the Cambrian siliceous dolomite outcrop samples collected from the Tarim Basin was measured at 2,644.89 kg/m³. The original rock samples were then processed into standard test specimens to investigate their mechanical properties, abrasiveness, and drillability.
1.1 Internal Structure and Mechanical Properties
The rock samples were sliced and prepared for microscopic observation. Figure 1 illustrates the microstructure of the rock at magnifications of 1.25x, 5x, and 10x. As can be seen, the dolomite exhibits strong heterogeneity, composed of numerous mineral grains with irregular, geometric shapes. These grains are clearly defined by distinct boundaries yet remain tightly interlocked. While dolomite is the primary mineral phase, quartz grains with irregular shapes are also present—remarkably, the quartz particles are larger in size compared to the dolomite grains.
The rock samples were machined into cylindrical specimens measuring Ø25 mm × 50 mm and Ø50 mm × 25 mm, which were used for uniaxial compression tests and Brazilian splitting tests to investigate the uniaxial compressive strength and uniaxial tensile strength of dolomite (Figure 2). The results revealed that the uniaxial compressive strength of dolomite reaches up to 221.51 MPa, while its tensile strength is 14.3 MPa. Compared to other deep-seated hard rocks, dolomite exhibits exceptionally high strength, making it particularly challenging to fracture.
1.2 Abrasiveness Test
During the drilling process, intense mechanical interactions continuously occur between the cutting teeth and the rock. The sliding friction between the cutting teeth and the rock surface leads to wear on the working face of the cutting teeth. To investigate the ability of dolomite to wear down drill bits during drilling, a "drill-grind" method was employed. Specifically, the grindability of siliceous dolomite was assessed using a standard wear-piece test: after the standard wear piece rubs against the rock, the grindability of the dolomite is characterized by measuring both the weight loss of the standard piece and the volume of rock fragments produced.

In this formula, λ represents the relative wear rate of the rock, measured in mg/cm³; ΔW denotes the weight loss of the standard wear specimen, in mg; and ΔV indicates the fractured volume of the rock, measured in cm³.
Table 1 presents the results of the abrasiveness experiment. The average relative wear rate obtained from the experiment was 4.97 mg/cm³. According to the abrasiveness classification scheme proposed by Huang Yong et al. [21], siliceous dolomite exhibits moderate abrasiveness.
1.3 Drillability Test
The drillability of rock refers to its ability to resist fracturing, serving as a critical basis for designing drilling operations—including selecting the appropriate drill bit type, optimizing bit design, and fine-tuning drilling parameters [22-23]. In this study, drillability tests were conducted according to the industry standard "Determination and Classification of Rock Drillability in Oil and Gas Drilling Engineering: SY/T 5426—2016, 3rd Edition" [24]. During the experiments, confining pressures were applied to the rock samples at gradients of 0 MPa, 10 MPa, 20 MPa, 30 MPa, 40 MPa, and 50 MPa. Figure 3 illustrates how the drillability grade of dolomite varies with increasing confining pressure. As shown, the drillability grade of siliceous dolomite rises steadily with higher confining pressures; however, once the pressure exceeds 30 MPa, the rate at which the drillability grade increases significantly slows down. Notably, when the confining pressure reaches 50 MPa, the drillability grade of siliceous dolomite already surpasses 10. According to the drillability grade classification table [24], this indicates that siliceous dolomite becomes extremely difficult to drill under such conditions. In reality, the confining pressures encountered in subsurface dolomite formations typically exceed 50 MPa, meaning that the drillability of siliceous dolomite would likely be even worse during actual drilling operations. Therefore, to achieve efficient drilling in dolomite formations, it is essential to enhance the aggressiveness of the drill bit.
2-bit drill design
Based on the drilling requirements for Well JT1 in the Tarim Oilfield, a PDC drill bit capable of efficient drilling in the Cambrian dolomite formation has been designed, with a diameter of 333.4 mm.
2.1 Preferred Cutting Teeth
The rock-breaking efficiency of PDC drill bits is closely tied to the characteristics of their cutting teeth [25-30]. PDC drill bits equipped with conventional flat teeth perform poorly in dolomite formations, facing significant challenges in both rock-breaking efficiency and overall tool life. To overcome the limitations of flat teeth, many researchers and oilfield service companies have developed drill bits featuring unconventional, or "shaped," cutting elements [31-36]. These shaped teeth eliminate the constraints imposed by traditional geometric designs, and compared to conventional flat teeth, their altered geometry not only changes how PDC cutters interact with the rock—modifying both the force distribution and the mechanism of rock failure—but also enhances the cutters' ability to withstand external forces such as abrasion and impact resistance [37-44].
In recent years, multi-faceted cutting teeth with multiple cutting edges have demonstrated outstanding performance in drilling deep geological formations. Using the finite element method and ABAQUS software, we simulated the rock-breaking process for both planar and multi-faceted teeth. The planar and multi-faceted teeth were modeled as rigid bodies, with a cutting speed set at 1.0 m/s. The rock was discretized into a mesh with elements sized at 0.2 mm, using C3D8R elements. General contact was defined between the cutting teeth and the granite, while self-contact was applied between internal elements within the rock. All contact interfaces featured a friction coefficient of 0.25. The rock material was governed by a modified linear Drucker-Prager yield criterion, and plastic strain was used as the primary indicator to determine rock failure during the breaking process [45]. Figure 4 illustrates the stress distribution patterns during rock breaking for both planar and multi-faceted teeth. During the process, the rock tends to first come into contact with the convex ridges of the multi-faceted teeth, with cutting forces applied either through point or line contact—conditions that significantly enhance rock fracture. Additionally, the unique ridge structure of the multi-faceted teeth provides superior penetration capabilities compared to their planar counterparts. Furthermore, when the drill bit experiences intense impact with the rock, the resulting shock force is effectively distributed across the multiple planar surfaces of the multi-faceted teeth. As drilling progresses and the formation becomes more abrasive, the convex ridges on the multi-faceted teeth gradually wear down, exposing the triangular central planes that then engage directly with the formation. These newly exposed planes act as additional cutting edges, enabling continued rock penetration and efficient cutting. Overall, multi-faceted teeth combine both shear and compressive mechanisms for rock breaking, offering exceptional aggressiveness, impact resistance, and abrasion tolerance. This results in high rock-breaking efficiency, low energy consumption, and makes them particularly well-suited for drilling through dolomite formations.
Figure 4: Stress Distribution Maps for Planar Teeth vs. Multi-Faceted Teeth in Rock Breaking
Figure 5 illustrates the cutting forces of planar and multi-faceted teeth when crushing dolomite under different confining pressures. Under high confining pressure conditions, the cutting force generated by the multi-faceted teeth was significantly lower than that of the planar teeth, indicating that multi-faceted teeth exhibit greater aggressiveness and require less energy in the high-pressure downhole environment. In terms of impact resistance, at a confining pressure of 50 MPa, the planar teeth showed the largest fluctuation in cutting force—exceeding 5,000 N—while the multi-faceted teeth experienced fluctuations no greater than 3,000 N. Thanks to their more stable cutting forces with minimal fluctuations, the multi-faceted teeth demonstrated superior impact resistance and enhanced stability during the rock-breaking process.
Figure 5: Cutting Force Test Results for Planar and Multi-Faceted Teeth Fragmenting Dolomite Under Different Confining Pressures
2.2 Crown and Blade Wing Design
The crown structure significantly influences the drill bit's stability, drilling performance, and steering capability. A well-designed crown shape not only enhances the bit’s stability but also facilitates efficient bottomhole cleaning and reduces wear on the cutting teeth. Currently, there are four primary crown shapes: mid-cone, flat-bottom, long-cone, and shallow-cone types [46]. Among these, the shallow-cone design features a smaller tooth-bearing area, enabling greater aggressiveness under the same drilling pressure. Additionally, the relatively flat crown of the shallow-cone bit requires lower flow rates while concentrating hydraulic energy more effectively, leading to superior cleaning action that efficiently removes cuttings from the wellbore. Therefore, to maximize drilling speed, bits with shallow-cone crowns are typically chosen. To further improve the bit’s resistance to impact forces, the crown curve is designed with a smoother transition—specifically, a "straight-line–arc–arc" profile—ensuring a more uniform distribution of drilling pressure across the cutting teeth. This arrangement helps maintain nearly identical cutting depths for each tooth. Moreover, the center of the crown arc is positioned as close as possible to the bit’s central axis, minimizing stress on the nose-area cutting teeth and thereby extending their service life. Field tests have consistently demonstrated that maintaining high stability and gauge protection during drilling through hard formations is critical [47]. However, while the shallow-cone crown design boosts the bit’s aggressiveness, it tends to exhibit poorer circumferential stability, often resulting in bit bounce and lateral vibrations. Research indicates that increasing the length of the gauge protection segment can significantly reduce lateral vibrations, enhancing overall drilling stability and improving wellbore wall quality [48-50]. To further reinforce both the bit’s circumferential stability and its ability to maintain proper gauge, the length of the gauge protection segment has been increased from the conventional 50.8 to 72.6 mm up to 101.6 mm. The optimized crown curve parameters now include an inner cone angle of 150°, a crown tip radius of 60.5 mm, an outer cone segment arc radius of 398.5 mm, and a gauge protection segment length of 101.6 mm.
On the other hand, the blade wings—being a crucial component in the structural design of PDC drill bits—affect both the tooth density and the bit’s overall performance through their shape and number. More blade wings generally enhance the drill bit’s rock-breaking stability and increase penetration rates; however, an excessive number of wings can reduce the bit’s aggressive cutting capability. Therefore, based on practical experience with PDC drill bits used in dolomite formations [20], it is recommended to adopt a straight seven-blade configuration with a "three long, four short" arrangement, ensuring optimal tooth density and drilling speed.
2.3 Tooth Profile Design
2.3.1 Rock Plastic-Brittle Critical Fracture Theory
The failure mode of rock is critical for cutter design and the selection of drilling parameters, significantly influencing drilling efficiency and well-drilling costs [51]. Numerous experimental results indicate that as the cutting depth gradually increases, the rock’s failure mode transitions from one type to another [52-53]. Specifically, when the cutting depth is relatively shallow, the rock undergoes plastic failure, producing small-volume, granular or powdery debris with lower rock-breaking efficiency. However, once the cutting depth exceeds a certain threshold, the rock begins to fail in a brittle manner, generating larger, blocky or flaky debris that enhances rock-breaking efficiency. Therefore, during the process of rock breaking by cutting teeth, there exists a critical cutting depth at which the rock’s failure mode shifts dramatically. Our research team has previously conducted extensive studies on this phenomenon [54-56], leading to the development of a specific formula for calculating the specific energy required to break rock—based on the transition between its plastic and brittle failure modes.

In this equation, MSE represents the rock-breaking specific energy, in MPa; η is a constant influenced by the rake angle; σc denotes the uniaxial compressive strength of the rock, in MPa; d refers to the cutting depth, in mm; dc represents the critical cutting depth, in mm; Kb is an influence factor related to the geometry of the cutting teeth (diameter, working face) and the rock properties, expressed in MPa·mm⁴/³; and Kp indicates the energy required to form the plastic deformation zone, in MPa.
In the rock plastic-brittle critical fracture theory, the critical fracture depth increases as the rake angle rises but decreases as the aggressiveness of the cutting teeth intensifies—note that the aggressiveness of the cutting teeth actually diminishes with an increase in their diameter. As shown in Equation (2), when the cutting depth falls below the critical depth, the rock undergoes plastic deformation, and the specific energy required for rock breaking becomes independent of the cutting depth. For a given rake angle and rock type, this specific energy remains constant. However, both the rake angle of the cutting teeth and the rock’s strength significantly influence the specific energy of rock breaking. On the other hand, once the cutting depth exceeds the critical threshold, the specific energy of rock breaking begins to decline continuously as the depth increases. When the cutting depth becomes sufficiently large, the specific energy of rock breaking eventually equals the material’s uniaxial compressive strength (Kp)—a scenario that poses a formidable challenge in terms of both the material properties of the cutting teeth and the loading conditions they must endure. By plotting the specific energy of rock breaking against the cutting depth, with d⁻⁴/³ serving as the horizontal axis and the energy as the vertical axis, we can more clearly visualize the relationship between these variables under specific rake angles and rock types (Figure 6).
Figure 6: Schematic Diagram Showing the Relationship Between Specific Rock Breakage Work and Cutting Depth for a Particular Rock Type
During actual drilling operations, the depth to which the drill bit's cutting teeth penetrate the formation—known as the critical penetration depth—is not always guaranteed to reach this threshold, thanks to the combined influence of factors such as formation pressure, mud column pressure, and drilling weight. Based on the rock’s plastic-to-brittle transition theory for critical fracture, once the type of rock being drilled is determined, two key adjustments can be made: First, by optimizing the rake angle of the cutting teeth, the specific energy required for rock breaking can be minimized under the plastic failure mode. Second, by fine-tuning the diameter and working surface geometry of the cutting teeth, the parameter Kb (related to rock breakage efficiency) can be reduced. These two adjustments collectively lower the critical penetration depth, making it easier for the rock to undergo brittle failure while simultaneously narrowing the gap in specific energy consumption between the plastic and brittle failure modes. As a result, the cutting teeth achieve higher rock-breaking efficiency with significantly reduced energy input during the drilling process.
2.3.2 Tooth Distribution Results
During the process of drilling into dolomite formations, PDC drill bits often suffer severe damage to their shoulder and nose cutting elements due to excessive single-tooth load. To address this issue, the newly designed drill bit features a dual-row arrangement of teeth on both the shoulder and nose sections of each blade, with an increased tooth density in these critical areas. This design effectively reduces the single-tooth load, enhancing the overall stability and impact resistance of the drill bit. The front-row teeth serve as the primary cutting elements, responsible for breaking down the rock, while the rear-row teeth act as backup tools, stepping in immediately once the front-row teeth show signs of wear. To prevent individual cutting elements from prematurely failing due to excessively high rock-breaking volumes within a given time frame, an even-cutting principle is applied during tooth placement. Additionally, the tooth density in the outer conical section leading up to the gauge area has been heightened, further boosting the PDC drill bit’s ability to penetrate tough interbedded layers and reinforcing its overall gauge protection capability. Based on the selected crown shape type and number of blades outlined earlier, the diameter and rake angle of the front-row primary cutting elements were comprehensively optimized using the rock plasticity-to-brittleness critical fracture theory. This optimization was combined with a force-balancing model [57], ensuring that the final tooth layout not only meets but exceeds the required mechanical performance standards—ultimately maximizing the drill bit’s overall rock-breaking efficiency while maintaining stable drilling operations. As a result of this refined design, the optimized front-row primary cutting elements now total 61, each measuring 15.88 mm in diameter.
Additionally, two conical teeth are installed at the rear end of the outer tapered surfaces of each cutting blade to absorb impact forces, thereby enhancing the drill bit's circumferential stability, its ability to repair wellbore walls, and its resistance to sticking. To prevent issues such as core removal or damage to the central cutting teeth, while simultaneously boosting the impact resistance of the drill bit's core area, three spherical limiting teeth are fitted into the inner tapered sections of the three longer blades. Furthermore, to ensure drill bit stability and improve wear resistance in the gauge section—thus avoiding the formation of annular grooves or diameter reductions—anti-friction elements are incorporated into the gauge segments of each blade. The tooth arrangement and 3D structure of the drill bit are illustrated in Figure 7.
Figure 7: Tooth distribution results and 3D structural diagram of the drill bit
2.3.3 Simulation Verification
To verify the feasibility and reliability of the optimized tooth arrangement design, a 3D numerical model of the designed PDC drill bit was created in ABAQUS software. This model simulated the rock-breaking process of the drill bit as it penetrated through dolomite under ambient temperature and pressure conditions. The drill body and PDC cutters were treated as rigid bodies, with an applied drilling force of 150 kN, a rotational speed of 60 r/min, and a loading duration of 25 seconds. The rock model had a compressive strength of 200 MPa, and its mesh size was set at 0.4 mm, using the C3D8R element type.
Figure 8-a shows the borehole formation results in the rock, while Figure 8-b illustrates the penetration rate, mechanical drilling speed, torque, and axial velocity of the PDC drill bit. The drill bit achieved an average mechanical drilling speed of 8.45 m/h and experienced an average torque of 8.01 kN•m. Axially, the drill bit exhibited minimal axial vibration. Numerical simulations of rock-breaking performance indicate that the PDC drill bit, designed based on the plastic-brittle critical fracture theory, demonstrates high mechanical drilling speeds and a remarkably smooth drilling process when used in high-strength rocks, resulting in excellent borehole quality. Theoretically, this approach could significantly enhance drilling efficiency in Cambrian dolomite formations.
Figure 8: Numerical Simulation Verification of Gear Tooth Design
2.4 Hydraulic Structure Design
During the drilling process, the drill bit damages the rock under the combined action of torque and weight on bit, generating significant amounts of cuttings at the bottom of the well. If these cuttings aren’t removed promptly, they can lead to repeated crushing and even bit balling, severely impacting drilling efficiency. Additionally, the intense and continuous mechanical interaction between the cutting teeth and the rock causes the temperature of the teeth to rise. Without timely cooling, this can result in severe wear and tear on the cutting elements. Drilling fluid is pumped through nozzles to reach the bottom of the well, where it effectively cleans the drill string, carries away the cuttings, and cools the cutting teeth—functions that are critical for maintaining drilling efficiency and preserving the mechanical integrity of the drill bit.
Due to the new drill bit design featuring seven cutting blades arranged in a "three long, four short" configuration, 10 nozzles have been strategically placed—each short blade is equipped with one nozzle, while each long blade has two nozzles—to ensure that all cutting teeth on every blade are effectively flushed by the drilling fluid. After the initial positioning and shape of the nozzles were determined, Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) software was used to simulate and analyze the flow field distribution at the bottom of the well. The drilling fluid was modeled as an incompressible fluid, with its viscosity set at 0.016 Pa·s and density at 1,400 kg/m³. Additionally, the fluid’s entry velocity into the nozzles was fixed at 5 m/s, while the exit pressure was maintained at 20 MPa.
By continuously optimizing and adjusting the nozzle position and shape, we obtained the final drilling fluid velocity streamlines and the resulting fluid flow rates on the drill bit body, as shown in Figure 9. The flow dynamics of the drilling fluid at the bottom of the wellbore and near the cutting teeth are critical factors influencing how effectively the drilling fluid performs its intended functions. As illustrated in Figure 9-a, the rational placement of the nozzles ensures that highly turbulent flow does not occur in the central region of the drill bit. Additionally, the distribution of fluid velocity and flow rate among the individual blades is remarkably balanced, which helps prevent mud packing while minimizing erosion of the drill bit substrate caused by the high-velocity fluid impact. The velocity distribution of the drilling fluid across the drill bit body is depicted in Figure 9-b. Notably, the fluid flows most rapidly at the shoulder and nose regions of the drill bit, where intense friction with the formation occurs. This robust flow not only efficiently cools the cutting teeth—areas subjected to extreme wear—but also effectively removes cuttings from the wellbore, preventing re-crushing and ultimately enhancing drilling efficiency.
Figure 9: Traces of Drilling Fluid Flow Velocity and Their Distribution on the Drill Bit Body
3 Field Tests
The design-based drill bit (model DS675H) was field-tested in the Lower Quli Tag Formation’s dolomite and siliceous dolomite sections of Well JT1 in the Tarim Oilfield. The drilling assembly used included: the DS675H drill bit, a downhole stabilizer tool, one 13 1/8" centralizer, a single 9" drill collar, another 13 1/8" centralizer, two additional 9" drill collars, 12 8" drill collars, an 8" mud motor with integrated shock absorber, three more 8" drill collars, five 5 7/8" heavy-weight drill pipes, and standard 5 7/8" drill pipes (1" = 25.4 mm). During the test, the DS675H drill bit achieved a penetration depth ranging from 2,311 to 2,914 meters, covering a total footage of 603 meters, with an average mechanical drilling rate of 2.87 meters per hour. Notably, this performance set new records for both the longest footage drilled by a single drill bit and the highest mechanical drilling rate ever recorded in the dolomite formations of the Tarim Oilfield.
3.1 Comparison of Speed-Up Across Wells in the Same Formation Segment
Figure 10 illustrates the performance comparison between the DS675H drill bit and the previous bit used in the same well and formation section, highlighting the increased drilling speed achieved by the DS675H (shown in orange). Geologically, the DS675H drill bit encountered formations with an average silica content of 2.26%, which is 14.1% higher than the average silica content of the formations drilled by the previous bit. Notably, the DS675H bit even encountered a formation with a maximum silica content of 14.13%, significantly surpassing the peak silica level observed with the earlier tool. In particular, the bit successfully penetrated two intervals characterized by exceptionally high silica content—between 2,378 and 2,419 meters, and from 2,773 to 2,835 meters—where the average silica levels were 4.99% and 4.80%, respectively. These two intervals collectively span approximately 100 meters in thickness (highlighted by the blue dashed boxes in Figure 10-a). Despite these challenging geological conditions, the DS675H drill bit delivered impressive results: it achieved a total footage of 603 meters, representing a remarkable 107.2% increase compared to the previous bit’s 291-meter run in the same formation section. Moreover, the DS675H demonstrated a 19% improvement in average mechanical drilling rate. In addition to its superior performance, the DS675H drill bit exhibited enhanced aggressiveness and efficiency, operating at an average weight-on-bit of 157.69 kN—15.4% lower than the average weight-on-bit of the previous tool. Furthermore, the DS675H maintained more stable drilling operations, with smaller torque fluctuations compared to the earlier bit, ensuring greater drilling stability throughout the process. Overall, based on field data, the DS675H drill bit has proven to be a highly effective solution for boosting drilling efficiency in this challenging formation.
Figure 10: Comparison Chart of Drilling Speed Improvement Between DS675H Drill Bit and Bits Used in the Same Well and Formation Section
3.2 Drill Bit Out-of-Well Analysis
Figure 11 shows the condition of the DS675H drill bit before entering the well and its overall state after retrieval. After being pulled out, a circular groove was observed at the center of the bit, located between the third and fourth teeth in the inner-cone section (indicated by the red dashed circle in Figure 11-b). This issue may be linked to insufficient hydraulic energy delivered by the three nozzles positioned at the bit’s central area: inadequate hydraulic power prevented efficient removal of cuttings, causing them to accumulate and repeatedly grind against the bit and well bottom. Additionally, this buildup likely resulted in ineffective cooling of the cutting teeth in that region, ultimately leading to the formation of the circular groove. Further optimization of the bit’s internal hydraulic design and tooth arrangement parameters is required. Notably, the first two cutting teeth on the three long blades at the bit’s center showed no significant damage. However, after prolonged drilling operations, severe tooth-face spalling was observed on the front-row cutting teeth along the shoulders of Blades Nos. 3 and 6. This phenomenon might stem from insufficient cooling efficiency of the drilling fluid in these specific areas, highlighting the need to refine the nozzle angles positioned ahead of Blades Nos. 3 and 6. Meanwhile, varying degrees of tip chipping were noted on the front-row cutting teeth at the shoulder sections of Blades Nos. 1, 2, 4, 5, and 7. Fortunately, wear on the rear-row teeth of the DS675H drill bit remained minimal, with only a few instances of slight tip chipping observed. Moreover, chipping was also detected at the tips of the front-row teeth along the outer-diameter arcs of each blade—indicating that further optimization of the tooth arrangement parameters in these critical areas is essential.
Figure 11: Overall condition images of the DS675H drill bit before and after being run into the well
4. Conclusions and Recommendations
1) The dolomite formation exhibits strong heterogeneity, a dense structure, and high strength, with a uniaxial compressive strength reaching 221.51 MPa. Grinding and drillability tests reveal that the dolomite formation has moderate abrasiveness and extremely poor drillability under high confining pressure conditions.
2) The highly efficient PDC drill bit, designed based on the plastic-brittle critical fracture theory, effectively enhances drilling performance in dolomite formations, delivering significant speed-up results. As a result, the footage per bit has been dramatically improved, breaking the current records for both the longest footage achieved by a single bit and the fastest mechanical drilling rate in the dolomite formations of the Tarim Oilfield.
3) Adopting a "shallow-cone crown + long gauge section" design effectively reduces torque fluctuations, thereby enhancing the drilling stability of PDC bits in dolomite formations.
4) To further enhance the drilling efficiency of PDC drill bits in Cambrian dolomite formations, it is necessary to optimize the bit's hydraulic design based on the DS675H drill bit structure. This optimization aims to improve the efficiency of cuttings removal by drilling fluid, as well as the cooling effectiveness of the center and shoulder cutting teeth, thereby extending the bit's service life and boosting its rock-breaking performance. Additionally, further refinement of the tooth arrangement parameters along the outer arc of the bit is required to minimize tooth tip chipping and enhance the bit's circumferential stability.
Chengdu Tdrill Energy Technology Co., Ltd.
Related News
The annual meeting of Chengdu Tdrill Energy Technology Co.,Ltd., themed "Leap into a New Journey, Achieve Success Today," has concluded successfully. All colleagues and guests gathered together to review past achievements, outline plans for the new year, recognize outstanding individuals, unite our strengths, and jointly embark on a new journey of high-quality development for the company.
2026 Spring Festival Holiday Notice
Our company is pleased to announce the 2026 Spring Festival holiday schedule: The holiday period will run from February 11, 2026 (the 22nd day of the 12th lunar month) to February 23, 2026 (the 7th day of the 1st lunar month). Normal office operations will resume on February 24, 2026 (the 8th day of the 1st lunar month). During the holiday period, routine business processing will be temporarily suspended. We will promptly respond to any inquiries or collaboration requests once we resume work. On this joyous occasion of the Spring Festival, our company extends festive greetings to all our valued customers. We deeply appreciate your long-term support and trust, and wish you a happy Spring Festival and smooth sailing in all your endeavors.
In oil drilling operations, the transition zone where the drill bit moves from soft rock formations into hard rock formations (or vice versa) is often a high-risk area for drill bit damage. A recent study, using sophisticated digital simulations, has revealed the underlying mechanical mechanisms behind this phenomenon and proposed effective solutions.